Pages

Monday 8 July 2019

Review For Samsung Galaxy S10

10th anniversary Galaxy is as close as Android gets to the complete package 


by  Tom Morgan
 
You know the drill by now: the arrival of a new Galaxy smartphone is as big as it gets in the Android world. Think Chrismukkah, 4th of July and pancake day all at once. Big.

That's a lot to pressure to deliver the goods, and with rivals rapidly gaining ground, Samsung has never had a tougher job of staying the de facto choice for anyone not interested in an iPhone.
The S10 is just one part of a three-prong plan of attack, from mainstream to full-on flagship, and might just be the best of the bunch.

DESIGN & FEATURES: WHATEVER YOU WANT

 
 

Does the handset in front of you look familiar? It should: Samsung hasn't really messed with its Galaxy phone formula for four years now, improving and iterating but keeping the same basic design intact. And why wouldn't you - the S10 is gorgeous.

The polished metal frame sandwiched between two pieces of glass is undeniably classy. It's a little bit taller, a little bit wider than the outgoing S9 - but not so much you'll notice.
A 6.1in screen sounds big, but with a narrow aspect ratio, it's skinny enough to sit comfortably in one hand. The screen still subtly curves around the sides, and the bezels are even skinnier than last year's already impressive S9.

Samsung has achieved that with some camera cleverness, bypassing notches and just cutting a hole right through the display to make room for the single selfie cam. It sits in the top right corner, and is sure to be just as divisive as a notch would be, but spend a bit of time with the S10 and you quickly forget it's there.

Around back, a triple-lens camera array takes pride of place - but more on that below. What you won't find is a fingerprint sensor, because Samsung has buried it underneath the screen. It uses ultrasonic tech, rather than optical, which makes it a little more accurate but no faster.

Because it doesn't light up when you rest a digit on it, however, lining up perfectly can be a bit of a challenge. Focus on what's new and you might miss returning features that have become Samsung staples, like the microSD card slot for adding extra storage (should you fill the generous 128GB of on-board memory) and the 3.5mm headphone jack, which is something of a novelty in a world where other flagships are happy to follow Apple down the path of dongles and adaptors.

The controversial Bixby button also hangs around, but you can at least set it to open another app if you don't use Samsung's personal assistant.

DISPLAY & SOUND: HOLE IN ONE


 

Whether you're a fan of the hole punch camera or not, there's no denying the screen it peeks through is one of the best you'll find on a phone. Remember when "Samsung AMOLED" was a byword for overly vibrant, super-saturated colours? Those days feel like a long way off now.

The S10 delivers accurate, true-to-life hues that are easy on the eye without becoming unnatural. Contrast is unparalleled, with deep, inky blacks and an uncanny ability to avoid reflections and screen glare.

You have the choice of 'natural' and 'vivid' colour modes (no more granular customisation like the Galaxy S9) but you honestly don't need to bother with them - the S10 looks its best right out of the box.

This is an HDR-certified panel, which means compatible Netflix clips and YouTube videos look outstanding. Brightness gets boosted to retina-burning levels, which also helps when you step outside. Even in direct sunlight, we had no trouble seeing what was onscreen.

For such a skinny phone, the S10 also has pretty potent set of speakers, making it a rather superb little multimedia machine. The stereo setup is louder than the S9's, with a clearer mid-range real clarity, although the addition of Dolby Atmos doesn't really add much to the mix.

CAMERA: TRIPLE CROWN

 

Here's where the S10 takes the biggest leap forward from last year. Whereas the S9 had a single 12MP snapper, its successor gets three: one variable-aperture sensor for general shooting, a 12MP telephoto for 2x zoom, and a 16MP ultra-wide for when you absolutely have to get everything into a single shot.

The main and zoom cameras both have optical image stabilisation, making the wide-angle camera the weakest of the three - it has no OIS and a narrower aperture. Still, as long as you feed it enough light, the trade-off is worth it for the expanded view it provides.

Switching between each camera is seamless, and combined give the kind of flexibility you'd need a camera bag full of lenses to pull off with a proper camera.

The pixel count may not have changed, but Samsung's software and image processing algorithms have learned a few more tricks. Auto HDR is now better able to cope with bright skies, exposure is more natural and the balance of highlights and shadows is all rather impressive.

You'd need to put an S10 side-by-side with an S9 to spot the (admittedly small) upgrades, but they are definitely there. In daylight, the S10's photos look great, with plenty of detail, accurate colours and well-judged exposure. Small details can sometimes be lost in the noise reduction and sharpening process, but you've got to zoom in to notice.

An Apple iPhone XS might stay a little more true-to-life and retain more subtle detail, but the Samsung's photos are often easier on the eye. It's low light where the S10 falters. It can still capture decent images, but the scene recognition system's night mode just can't compete with the Huawei Mate 20, Google Pixel 3 ot the unbeatable P30 Pro.

Ultimately though, and considering every day use - do you want outright quality or the versatility of multiple lenses? For most people, the S10's photos will be more than good enough.
 

PERFORMANCE: EXYNOS IS ENOUGH

 

The silicon you'll find underneath the S10's glorious glass body depends on where you live. Much of the world gets Qualcomm's fastest mobile chip, the Snapdragon 855, but here in the UK we get one of Samsung's own Exynos 9820 CPUs.

This only really matters if you're into benchmark scores, as the Exynos loses out to the Snapdragon in popular tools like Geekbench. It even falls behind Huawei's Mate 20 Pro on paper, and lags behind the iPhone XS too.

But for everyone else, all you need to know is that the S10 is still crazy quick, with no lag, stutter or slowdown noticeable in any app or game we threw at it. 8GB of RAM certainly helps. A built-in device maintenance mode should keep that performance strong a year down the line, too.

Gaming is where the S10 catches up, besting the Mate 20 Pro and delivering frame rates on par with the top Snapdragon phones. If you're hankering for a bit of Fortnite on the go, know that this phone will play smoothly at the highest settings, even when the going gets tough.

BATTERY LIFE: IS THAT ALL YOU'VE GOT?

 

The S10 isn't lacking for performance, then, but it could perhaps use a bit more staying power. A 3400mAh battery isn't huge, and with a power-hungry Exynos chip to keep ticking over, you'll be lucky to last an entire day without dipping into the power saving modes.

Video and games are naturally the biggest energy sappers, eating as much as 20% battery for a single hour of HDR Netflix streaming. It's a similar story with 3D games, so claiming a PUBG Mobile win could drain a fifth of your total charge.

Stick to simpler stuff like social media, music and email, and you'll get to bedtime without running out completely, but you'll want to recharge overnight. It takes an hour and a half to go from empty to full using Samsung's bundled USB-C charger - not outstanding, but hardly slow either.

Wireless charging adds a bit of convenience, and you can even share power with other Qi-compatible gadgets if you like, although considering the S10 isn't the longest-lasting phone, you'll perhaps want to stick to giving your wireless earbuds a quick zap rather than offering to refuel a friend's dead phone.

It's not fast, and you've got to toggle it on whenever you want to give it a whirl.

OS & SOFTWARE: PIE MEETS ONE UI



With a new version of Android to show off on the S10, Samsung took full advantage and overhauled its interface completely.

The new One UI is much simpler than before, with apps optimised to make things easier to reach on taller, skinnier phones. That's great - if you use Samsung's apps. Most of us are quite happy with Google's web browser, email app, image gallery and the like, so it can feel a bit redundant.
The notification tray and Settings menu get the biggest visual shake-up, so while you might have to dig a menu or two deeper to find the exact setting you want, overall things are easier to navigate. A night mode switches system colours from white to black, which helps stop the screen from searing your eyeballs when scrolling at night.

Android 9.0 Pie has introduced digital wellbeing, to help you keep tabs on your phone habits and dial things back a bit if you're spending too much time on Facebook or Instagram. You have to set timers manually for each feature, so there's still a fair bit of willpower involved.

The home screen launcher feels familiar, with the app drawer revealed by an upwards swipe. It feels a little sparse out of the box, but it's easy enough to ramp up the density and fit more apps onscreen at once.

Samsung has stuck with the typical Home, Back and Recents navigation, albeit in a backwards order to the Android norm. You can quicky swap 'em round again, or go for gesture controls instead. Importantly, beyond the visual changes this still feels like a Samsung phone, so returning users will feel right at home.

SAMSUNG GALAXY S10 VERDICT

Is the S10 the most powerful smartphone around? Does it have the very best screen? Can it last the longest between charges? We're used to Samsung setting the gold standard for Android, so it's hard to believe the answer to all those questions is "no".

Keen photographers will get excellent results (especially in low light) from a Google Pixel 3, or the Huawei P30 Pro. Plus, the Huawei Mate 20 Pro and P30 Pro have even greater stamina.

A OnePlus 6T is much better value. But the S10 is an incredibly well-rounded Android on every other front.

Handset prices have been creeping ever higher over the past few years, and £800 SIM-free is mighty pricey, but it does undercut the Apple iPhone XS by £200 and feels mo. That amount does mean it exists in a strange sort of middle ground, with the S10+ boasting a bigger screen and longer-lasting battery for only a little more cash, and the S10e being much more affordable with only a few minor concessions.

Still, if you've got to have the best Samsung and arguably the best Android, yet don't see the point in twin selfie cameras or ridiculous zooming capabilities, the S10 is pretty much all the phone you'd ever need.

 Tech Specs

Samsung Galaxy S10 review

The S10 is better than ever. The mainstream Galaxy might now play middle child to more powerful and more affordable variants, but there's nothing else running Android that's quite as well-rounded.
 
Good Stuff 
Truly versatile three-lens camera
Gorgeous display and top-notch performance
Feature-packed in ways few rivals can match
 
Bad Stuff 
In-display finger scanner not perfect
Not the best battery life
Price hike makes the S10e a tempting alternative
 
 

Review For Huawei P30 Pro

Huawei go again: Updated with image gallery and verdict 




by  Natalya Paul
 
It seems crazy to think that less than a decade ago, non-nerds didn’t know what Huawei was. Now it’s a company as ubiquitous as a Pret a Manger branch in the capital and was second, after Samsung, for selling the most smartphones in 2018.

There’s no denying that the Chinese company is terrifyingly capable at making phones. The Huawei Mate 20 Pro was awarded king smartphone by this very publication, and it’s not the sort of company to rest on its laurels either; its latest project, the Mate X literally folds in half.

And since the roaring success of the photographic-focused P20 Pro, excitement for the P30 Pro hasn’t dwindled. We’ve been following the leaks like a ravenous fox hunting out a particularly succulent rabbit.

And it just so happens that we were in Paris for the launch, where rabbits are commonplace on the dinner table.
Now, after spending a week with it, we get the skinny on Huawei’s latest quad-camera, seriously shiny superstar.

Design and display: Second nature 


Before we get to the important things, can we just talk about the colours. Because they are quite sublime and Huawei has been waxing lyrical about the pearlessence and the iridescence and using many other adjectives which sound like they were conjured by a 90s Disney Princess.

The designs are ‘Inspired from nature’ and are quite stunning, regardless of their pretentious names. There’s Pearl White, Breathing Crystal (yep, you read that correctly), Amber Sunrise and Aurora – oh and if you’re really boring and basic like us, it’s available in black.

It’s all glass which curves around the edges, with the most miniscule of bezels possible, plus - a small dew drop at the top.

It’s got a waterproof rating of IP68, a tiny notch above the P20 Pro and enough for you to feel it’s safe should it take a dip.

Rocking the largest screen in this series, it’s a 6.47in OLED FHD+ display with a 2340x1080 resolution. From our time with the phone, while is might not look as sharp as the Mate 20 Pro, it’s still plenty screen with popping colours.

Huawei was able to reduce the size of the notch from the P20 Pro to give users a fuller view display by replacing the speaker with an electro magnetic levitation mechanism which sends vibrations to the entire screen enabling sound. This will also change the way you hear sound.

For instance, if someone sat next to you on the train is on the phone, you can sometimes hear the person chirping on the other end. With the P30 Pro – that won’t be possible.

At 192g, it feels substantial in the hand. Leave it on the very edge of a surface though and its slippery all glass body will go sliding off the end like it's got a death wish. 

And back to the iridescent colours – after handling the Aurora colour (pictured) this thing will pick up smudges at the first opportunity. Interestingly, we've been using the Amber Sunrise this week which is slightly less shiny and less susceptible to finger marks - yet no less beautiful. 

Software and performance: Kirin to a screen near you 

 

The P30 Pro munches on Huawei's latest processor - the Kirin 980, which is powerful, fast and intelligent, just like Huawei’s flagship – the Mate 20 Pro. The new processor (the Kirin 985) is not likely to reveal itself until the Mate 30 Pro comes to the fore.

Huawei employs EMUI 9.0, a version of the latest Android 9 operating system. This means more ‘AI’, where the way you use your phone will be stored and used to predict your next move –in theory this should mean you can zip though the phone with total fluency. Although we didn’t have long enough with it to get a real sense of this, we can definitely confirm that it’s fast.

There are some cool features (well depending on what you consider cool) – such as AI video editor which creates little video highlights for each person who you video or photograph regularly, not that dissimilar to what Google Photos does.

There’s also a downtime option whereby you can set some off-screen time which, although nothing new, is still a nice touch. The phone display will turn grey to reduce the desire to pick it up for just one more scroll.

The gestures also come to the P30 Pro, where you can swipe up to return home, or swipe up and hold to open up the task manager.

There’s lots of other new software tricks too including Digital Car Key, where Huawei is working with Audi to use the phone as a key to lock and unlock the car and even start the engine. There was no car to test this with at the briefing but while that feels pretty cool, it’s a bit of a shame that it's a feature reserved for Audi drivers.

One Hop also comes to the P30 Pro which we’ve seen on the MateBook X - which is a dream for professionals allowing the user to scan, copy and paste and transfer files with just one touch.
And the new in-screen finger-print scanner has been improved both on security and speed. We experienced no delay and it was always effortless to get into the phhone. 

It should have all the stamina you need - with the same 4,200 mAh battery as the Mate 20 Pro, and will go from 0-70% in a mere 30 minutes charge with fast charging. And, should you find yourself running out of steam and near another (consenting) Huawei phone, back-to-back wireless charging is available. 


Camera: Get lossless


 

 

Now above all, this is a photographic phone, which will no doubt become famed for its camera just as its predecessor was. The P30 Pro should set the bar even higher.

Firstly looking at the camera array on back, you get: a 40MP 27mm f/1.6 wide-angle main sensor, a 20MP ultra wide-angle 16mm f/2.2 and an 8MP 5x optical periscope zoom lens, plus a ToF lens which we first saw on an Oppo prototype at MWC this year.

On paper, the zoom lens gets the nod of approval - it’s really impressive. Especially the image stabilisation as we zoomed to over 10x, I could feel the camera working hard to counteract my wobbling. There are colouring issues as expected as you zoom in closer, but that would be expected on any camera. 

The company promises 10x lossless zoom. How? In short, thanks to a combination of the P30 Pro’s focal length (equivalent of 135mm for an optical zoom of 7.8x), and data from the main camera sensor which pushes it to that 10x figure. It's almost addictive to go zoom-crazy when you've got this phone in your hand. The detail is incredible at both 5x and 10x, things start to look a little bit undefined when you start going over 15x, but it'll still manage more than the likes of my iPhone XS max or a Pixel 3. 

The front facing camera has upped to 32MP – which is arguably more detail than anyone could possibly want. Maybe that’s just us though. Portrait mode works well on selfies and even in dim lighting – the photos are bright. There’s ‘beauty’ mode again which, thankfully, can be switched off.
Huawei, with Leica, have manufactured a new SuperSpectrum Sensor, so instead of RBG it uses RYYB. What this means to us simple folk is that more light can be absorbed. From swapping the green to yellow – as yellow can take in both green and red, there is more light information to work with, therefore, crisper photos.

The only tiny niggle we had with the camera was the rendering of green, taking the phone with me on a woodland walk, some of the foliage looked a little too vibrant and saturated, which, might just be a preference as I prefer more natural tones. 

Light Sensitivity ISO up to 400,000 from 102400 on the P20 Pro which means this should work wonders for night shooting – there's exposure time for 6 seconds whereby you must keep the phone really steady. When this was done successfully, night mode is unbelievable. Far more than what the human eye can decipher that's for sure. Night Mode takes multiple frames at varying exposures and then combines them into a single HDR image.

The new ToF camera sits above a light – they work in sync so that the sensor can accurately record how long it takes for the light to be reflected back off an object. This is handy for accurate reading of objects and also great for increasing depth and bokeh. In theory, the camera array should have a better understanding of the content. Portraits, in good light were mostly excellent, but in low light we did have some slight focusing issues. 

If video is more your bag, there’s a new dual view video which uses two cameras at the same time. So you can basically be filming two things at once – which sounds all kinds of crazy and actually quite mind boggling. We could really do with an extra brain to keep tabs on one of the frames.
Imagine if you’re shooting a football match, have one camera on the entire pitch and another closing in on the action. Yet it’s all recorded as a single video.

Huawei also promise excellent low light performance in video mode – we'd need to spend a lot more time shooting some, er, B-roll to really see if Spielberg would be impressed.

Huawei P30 Pro initial verdict



With the same processor and battery as the Mate 20 Pro and after spending a week with it, we've got no reservations about the P30 Pro's performance.

What this smartphone is really about is the camera. There's a complex setup involved and the periscopic zoom, plus the ToF sensor is exciting for a number of reasons. But for us, it's the accuracy. All too often smartphone bokeh isn't quite on the money, because a small chuck of hair gets chopped off, or the fraying threads on a knitted jumper, or the software just does something kooky. 

The P30 Pro sets a stratospheric benchmark of zooming capabilities on smartphones at no compromise to battery life or performance. The cleverly designed periscopic lens means you can zoom crystal clear at 5x, seriously good at 10x and then at 50x it'd be posssible to see the craters on the moon on a clear night. 

That's not to say it's perfect, focusing could be imporved as well as over-saturation, particularly on shades of green. But no smartphone will be able to match the P30 pro on a number of photography scenarios.

The beauty of the P30 Pro and its incrediblly zoom credentials is that it's not just all software gumph with time, there's been an impressive update to the hardware - and that marks the spot where partnering with Leica proves that pooling talent is where real advancement lies. 

Huawei P30 Pro review

The P30 Pro sports a camera array that’ll have its competitors calling for emergency meetings. It’s not just all software, there’s been an impressive update to the hardware, resulting in what is an unbeatable zoom on a smartphone camera.

 
Good Stuff 
Unbeatable zoom
Stunning images
Speedy performance
Bad Stuff 
no headphone jack
screen could be better